Monday, November 15, 2010

Is it All an Illusion?


            Illusion, the very word seems to be alluding its own meaning. In my initial research, I’ve come to find that the word is an illusion itself, meaning more than I thought it originally did. It may seem odd, but I like the sly personality of the word. An illusion can be anything we want it to be, so long as it deceives the eye or mind in some way. Everything and anything can be an illusion—are humans illusions of themselves? Is life an illusion? Or perhaps it might be better to ask: what isn’t an illusion? While pondering these deep questions, I’ve had some time to do a bit of research on the etymology, definitions, and use of the word illusion.
            The word in its present form is old French from the mid fourteenth century, but its roots (as those of most French words) are Latin. The Latin definition is a mocking, jesting, or irony and the Latin verb illudere translates as to mock. Thus, the original old French meaning was a mocking or act of deception. This correlates with the first definition listed in the Oxford English Dictionary (OED), the action of deriding or mocking. Furthermore, the word has always held the connotation of deception and trickery. One of the word’s first uses is in Richard Rolle of Hampole’s prose, where “illusyone of de enemy” is mentioned. Interestingly, illusions often seem to be associated with the devil. In Shakespeare’s Henry VIII the surveyor speaks of the “devil’s illusions”. This relationship with the devil connects illusion with magic. Illusion developed to mean an apparition or ghost and is often mentioned in the context of magic. In Hamlet Horatio cries, “Stay illusion!” to the ghost of the late king of Denmark. However it seems that illusion did not develop one of its more modern meaning of an “apparent perception of an external object when no such object is present” until the 1770s (OED). There appears to have been a kind of resurgence in the popularity of illusions. Houdini, the great illusionist, captured the world with his unworldly magic acts while Freud and other psychoanalysis emphasized the illusion of the subconscious. All of a sudden illusion became pop culture, further evident in the trendy Op Art of the 50s and 60s. I’d like to investigate how “the art of illusion” had its own renaissance in the fields of psychoanalysis, art, and magic in the 1900s.
            So far its been interesting to note where the word illusion has not come up. There is no trace of the word in the bible, as it is too young for such an old text. It does not once come up in Any of Lewis Carroll’s works, which was quite surprising to me considering the hallucinogenic descriptions of Wonderland. There isn’t a trace of it in Jane Austen’s writing or several other Victorian authors. It seems odd to me that illusion was such a rarely used word. I believe that its use must have greatly increased thanks to its famous proponents from a variety of spheres in the twentieth century. (513)

Tuesday, October 19, 2010

The Ellesmere Chaucer (Blog #6)


            Among the first manuscripts of The Canterbury Tales, the Ellesmere manuscript, also known as the Ellesmere Chaucer, holds an important place in literary and art history. The work is remembered today for both its textual and visual authority: it remains one of the best orderings of the tales and an epitome of medieval illuminated manuscripts.
            The significance of the Ellesmere Chaucer might best be understood with a description of how the Canterbury Tales have come down to us nearly six centuries later. The tales were always a work in progress for Chaucer. He wrote them in no particular order and left many unfinished. Moreover, unlike the unique Beowulf manuscript of which there is only one, over eighty different manuscripts, including fragments, have been identified. The problem deepens as none of these can be certainly dated in Chaucer's own lifetime, nor traced to a scribe directly employed or supervised by him. This means that nearly all the surviving manuscripts were written between 1400 and the time of Caxton's printing press less than a century later at which point the expense and tedium of hand-copying no longer seemed worthwhile. The Ellesmere manuscript is thought to have been written shortly following Chaucer’s death and possibly by the scribe Adam Pinkhurst, a man employed by Chaucer himself. The manuscript is therefore noted as a critical source for efforts to reconstruct Chaucer's original text and intentions. As Pinkhurst was acquainted with Chaucer, he might have had a better insight into Chaucer’s intentions for the Tales. Other arrangements of the stories have been tried, but the “Ellesmere order” (with a couple of changes) still serves to this day as the basic arrangement.
            The book itself remains of great worth not only for its textual contribution but also for its outstanding workmanship. Fortunately, the original Ellesmere manuscript survives to this day largely undamaged, due to the fact that it has rested in libraries since around 1600. The manuscript is beautifully bound and printed on 232 pages of the finest quality thin vellum, sound and flexible. The page dimensions are noteworthy, nearly 16 x 11 inches. However, the main glory of the manuscript is the lavish illumination and illustration, in which the Ellesmere is easily unrivaled. On no less than seventy-one pages large foliated initials are joined to "demi-vinet" borders (conventionalized vines), in gold and other colors, framing the text on three sides. Opposite the first line of each tale is the figure of that tale’s narrator. There are twenty-three highly individualized portraits, including a very famous one of Chaucer himself. The miniatures are of great charm and interest and all show a perfect understanding of the text they are intended to illustrate, unusual for medieval illustrations. Studies of illumination indicate that the manuscript was probably the work of three to four craftsmen and, interestingly, not of monks. The evidence suggests that the text, border, and figures were all done at the same time, also unusual for medieval manuscripts.  

The first page of the knight's tale. The demi-vinet and the knight's miniature are both visible.
            Thus the significance of the Ellesmere Chaucer is impressive: it is one of the two or three earliest manuscripts, one of the best authorities for the order of the tales, and one of the most splendid examples of medieval bookmaking. The Ellesmere Chaucer is easily the finest manuscript of The Canterbury Tales and is in every respect worthy of Chaucer himself.
A portrait of Chaucer.

Sunday, October 17, 2010

The Man of Law


          Chaucer presents the “Sergeant of the Lawe” exactly as a man of law: he strictly follows regulations and does nothing against the law. He owns his land without legal impediments and assures that all his purchasing “might not been infect” (322). Apparently, “every statut coude he plein by rote” (329) or, in other words, he could recite every statue by heart. He had memorized all of the laws, court cases, and decisions in England over the last 300 years and could therefore, Chaucer contends, write the most perfect legal document. Chaucer here is poking fun at the notion that memorization is akin to knowledge. The judge is wise and great, not because he is a great thinker or moralist, but because he can recite a law on demand.
            Despite his legal fastidiousness, the lawyer also has a bit of a more indulgent streak in him. He has grown rich lately, buying many nice robes and pursuing the path of a wealthy and powerful landowner.  He seems to enjoy this newfound reputation, meeting often in the prestigious porch of St. Paul’s Cathedral with his clients. He obviously takes pleasure in creating a persona about him to maintain his stature. As Chaucer writes: “Nowher so bisy a man as he her nas; / And yit he seemed bisier than he was” (324-5). The lawyer plainly likes to give off the impression of being wanted and valued by others for his work, however false this reputation may be. 
            Although it’s hard to tell, Chaucer was probably satirizing both the judicial system and the justice in this short snapshot. Chaucer mocks the so-called wisdom of the judge who really only memorizes court cases and decisions rather than thinking for himself. Perhaps Chaucer also hoped to express some appreciation for the emerging middle class. Most likely between the aristocratic and the middle class, the lawyer was a character who could travel across boundaries and expeirience the glamour of the wealthy and the streets of London. The lawyer does not fit into the traditional three estates and must therefore secure his high-ranking status through hard work, bragging, and in general being a bit of a poser. (361)

Sunday, September 19, 2010

Heorot Restored to Former Glory, Feasting and Celebration Abound!

The Mead Hall at Heorot,

          Alas, we are freed of the constant terror of the beast Grendel! The valiant and brave warrior Beowulf  (whose arrival we reported earlier) has murdered the evil kinsman of Cain. Grendel’s arm remains hanging from Heorot’s wall as a trophy of that great battle. Many a warrior attempted to rid Heorot of its pest, but for twelve long winters our once magnificent mead hall remained haunted. Only Beowulf has succeeded in destroying the monster, and for his courageous deed we are forever grateful.
            The victory feast was a great affair, and brought many back to the days when feasting and celebration were common in Heorot. The great hall was restored to much of its former glory (though Hrothgar has reported that he will be conducting some internal renovations promptly to update the decoration and replace destroyed parts), with banners, tapestries, and streamers aligning the walls and roof. The center of attention was upon our heroic savior, Beowulf. All praised and congratulated him. His fame and renown is already traveling far: horsemen departed Heorot early this morning to begin spreading Beowulf’s glory. Soon all men will know of his great strength, courage, and generosity. The celebration was soon underway in the majestic hall. A bard recounted Beowulf’s battle and even compared him to the noble dragon-slayer, Sigemund. It is important to note that throughout the festivities and the praising of Beowulf, no one forgot about our great King Hrothgar or denied his eminence as our ruler.
            Perhaps the most moving moment of the festivities was Hrothgar’s figurative adoption of Beowulf. Sitting between the two princes, Hrethic and Hrothmund, Beowulf graciously accepted Hrothgar’s affection and spoke of his respect for the king and his wonderful mead hall. As must be done to reward an honored warrior, treasures were bestowed in abundance. From the Danish treasury, Hrothgar presented Beowulf with a gold-wove banner, a broidered battle-flag, breastplate and helmet, a spending sword, and a few decorated steeds. Our great warrior accepted such illustrious gifts with alacrity. Hrothgar also made sure to pay the death-price for the Geatish warrior Grendel killed. Then, to continue the cheer and merry mead drinking, Hrothgar’s singer filled the hall with the saga of Finn, recounting that sad story of broken peace between us Danes and the Frisians. We shall never forget the plight of Hildeburh, but still wish the best for Freawuru and her betrothed, Ingeld the Heatho-Brad.
            To conclude the evening of merriment, our wise and lovely queen Wealhtheow made her presence known in a moving speech. She spoke confidently of her trust in Hrothful in guiding her sons and the kingdom when Hrothgar (praised be his heroic name) perishes. She addressed Beowulf with utmost respect and asked him too to be a mentor and friend of her sons. Expressing her great thanks to the strong warrior, the queen presented Beowulf with a rare and beautiful torque of gold and a suit of mail armor. And thus, the feast continued into the wee hours of the morning, with much mead drinking and celebration. Heorot is restored to glory, but one can’t help thinking that the struggle is not completely over yet. (525)
Reporting done by Hreporter for the Hrothgar's Heroic Herald

Sunday, September 12, 2010

Beowulf Passage Analysis

Page 63, lines 1518-1536

This passage portrays Beowulf struggling in the midst of battle with Grendel’s mother in the depths of the lake when he realizes that his sword is not strong enough to defeat the beast. Besides this moment of revelation, this selection is of significance for its vivid use of words and senses, both visually and orally. The aspect that struck me at first are the paired sets of words that seem to match each other so well in sound. Beowulf “heaved his war-sword and swung his arm” so that “the decorated blade came down ringing and singing on her head” (63). The combination of heaved and swung, especially with the similar-sounding sword, produces a nice set of sounds when said aloud and seem to fit the picture very well. The following set of ringing and singing, with their rhyme and strong sensory appeal (visually and audibly), only accentuate the first pair. The last duo in line 1530, fame and name, likewise fit together well in sound and meaning to enhance the second paragraph.

Also of note in the passage is the verb choice. I particularly like the use of the verb bite instead of cut when referring to the sword. The narrator says, “the shining blade refused to bite” (63). Bite is quite unusual, but strangely suitable in this case and does conjure a stronger image. The use of the verb hew is also interesting, it being somewhat of an onomatopoeia. The hard-sounding verb flung is also well placed in its context—the word fury is just before—and this small alliteration adds more emphasis to the “f” sound. The combination of the hard sounds, unusual verbs, and onomatopoeias add another dimension of appeal to this selection.

In addition to striking word choice and combination, the change in tone and perspective in the passage are also interesting. At first the tone is a bit depressed as Beowulf continues to struggle against the monster and his sword doesn’t work. The narrator says, “Here at last / the fabulous powers of that heirloom failed” (63). Then the tone lightens up as Beowulf regains confidence in his own strength. Furiously flinging his sword away, he decides (in a very dramatic, but inspiring move) to “rely / on the might of his arm” (64). The final shift in tone occurs in the next two sentences. Here the perspective changes from Beowulf’s to what comes off as the narrator in a direct address to the audience. It is written: “So must a man do / who intends to gain enduring glory / in combat. Life doesn’t cost him a thought” (64). These sentences have an instructional and almost preacher like tone about them, as if the narrator wants to inform his audience that a great warrior must only rely on his own strength to gain glory and that life shouldn’t be on the mind at a time like this. After all, it is all in a day’s work to be fighting a vicious monster underwater in a lake. I personally always enjoy little interjections like these from the narrator. They kind of ground the story back to reality in an unintentionally comical way, at least in my opinion. Overall, I thought this passage was engaging for its imagery, unique word choice, and somewhat silly narration. (545)

Wednesday, August 25, 2010

Inspired & Inspiring Reads

1. His Dark Materials, Philip Pullman (includes The Northern Lights, The Subtle Knife, and The Amber Spy Glass). I read these books a couple years ago and have loved them ever since. Though generally classified as young teen literature, the trilogy has some really deep thoughts and symbolism regarding the loss of innocence and the gaining of knowledge, organized religion, and humanity. It really shouldn't be put in the young adult section at Borders.

2. Eugene Onegin, Alexander Pushkin. As an introduction to Russian literature I couldn't have asked for anything better or more thoroughly enjoyable. I really enjoyed Pushkin's witty and often harsh sense of humor, especially regarding the melodramatic poet Lenski.

3. Harry Potter, J. K. Rowling. As my introduction to reading and ,you could say my first literary love, the Harry Potter series will always hold a place in my heart. Harry Potter is more than just a couple of books, it's a culture. When you grow up attending midnight book releases and making your own versions of the movies with friends, how could it be anything else?

4. Outlander, Diana Gabaldon. I love historical fiction as a literary genre and this series is a perfect example of great historical fiction. The books are so well researched that I'm always surprised by how much I've learned from reading them. Though I must admit that Diana Gabaldon has set my standards for men rather high with Jamie.

5. Murder on the Orient Express, Agatha Christie. My first Agatha Christie book and introduction to serious mystery, that is, beyond Nancy Drew. For some people the long interviews of suspects and always seemingly insane conclusions that nobody could ever guess are frustrating, but for me it all adds to the allure and intrigue of each book. I don't know who could top Poirot in detective flair and charm.

6. Daisy Miller, Henry James. A small novel, or novelette, with big ideas. I had a good time exploring Daisy Miller's innocence or lack thereof and James' fascination with life opportunities lost to society's decisive judgments.

7. Dead Souls, Nikolai Gogol. Another Russian with a wicked literary voice and sense of humor. Besides maybe J.D. Salinger I can't think of an author with a stronger narrative voice than Gogol. I would even say that Gogol might top his mentor Pushkin in this department. There were times that I laughed out loud while reading this.

8. SuperFreakonomics, Steven Levitt and Stephen Dubner. Some of the statistics and facts presented are completely mind boggling. The chapter on global warming entitled "What do Al Gore and Mount Pinatubo have in common?" opened my mind to an entirely different viewpoint of the problem and the best immediate solutions.

9. Angus, Thongs, and Full-frontal Snogging, and the 9 following books all by Louise Rennison. These are my guilty pleasure books. They may be complete trash in terms of literature but they are the funniest things I have ever read. From the main character's, Georgia's, hysterical antics to her hilarious vocabulary (there is a glossary) these books never fail to calm me down or make me laugh.

10. All Creatures Great and Small, James Herriot. Although I did not initially think of it, All Creatures Great and Small was one of my favorite reads as a tween. It reminds me of all the things I love about Britain and brings up memories of my own childhood in the English countryside. As in Herriot's books, it really isn't uncommon to go and see the annual lambing (lambs giving birth in spring).

Monday, August 23, 2010

Playing With Fire


Summer Reading:
Persuasion, Jane Austen
The Screwtape Letters, C.S. Lewis
            The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo,
            The Girl who Played with Fire,                 All Stieg Larsson
            The Girl who kicked the Hornet’s Nest (I’m about of 1/3 the way through),
War & Peace, Leo Tolstoy (about a ¼ of the way through)

            I have to admit with some hesitation that the book that has been on my mind most this summer is The Girl who Played with Fire, part of Stieg Larsson’s Millennium Trilogy. Though not the most intellectually stimulating of the books on my list, the sensitive topics explored throughout the book, its fascinating characters, ludicrous plot, and questionable viewpoints of the author have been running through my mind lately. 
            All three novels of the trilogy explore the issues of gruesome crime, drug trafficking, the sex trade, and most prominently misogyny. In fact, the original title of the first book was Men Who Hate Women. The Girl who Played with Fire carries on with the same principle characters of Lisabeth Salander, an asocial young woman with a history of abuse and mistreatment by the authorities, and Mikael Blomkvist, a bold journalist and personal friend of Salander. In the second installment Lisabeth is convicted of murdering Blomkvist’s fellow journalist, Dag Svensson, who is about to publish a glaring exposé of the Swedish sex trade. The novel takes its readers into the vile world of sex trafficking, specifically the punters who seek out the girls and then mistreat them. For example, one punter forces his girls to remain drunk or high in order to subdue them for his clients. While the novel mostly revolves around the inspection of the crime and Lisabeth’s activities, the scenes of gross violence remain most powerfully in my mind. One of the scenes that still haunts me is Lisabeth’s description of the treatment she received as a supposedly insane child in a psychiatric hospital that she was wrongly forced in to. She recounts the pleasure and enjoyment it gave her doctor, Mr. Teleborian, to see her strapped down to her bed helpless. So what’s the appeal of a series dominated by sick thoughts and violence? Even though I sometimes found it very difficult to fall peacefully asleep after reading into the wee hours of the morning, The Girl who Played with Fire was definitely a fascinating and worthwhile read. The story line is addictive and the characters so odd and different. How often is a vertically challenged, tattooed, computer hacking genius, asperger-ish murder suspect the protagonist of a novel? The Girl who Played with Fire is fun and intriguing not only for its scattered and unrealistic plot but also for its social context.
            Sweden is apparently a country of not so uncommon sexual abuse. Before Stieg Larsson brought it to the forefront, sexual mistreatment was already a relevant issue in Sweden.  A couple of years ago I visited the European Parliament in Brussels and walked across the office of the Swedish members of parliament. Their doors were covered with such messages as: “More and more Swedish men do their shopping over the Internet. It's a crime to buy sex”. I found that odd at the time and reading the trilogy has only further made me wonder why the usually unmentioned Scandinavian country of Sweden has this strong presence of prostitution. I also can’t decipher my feelings towards Stieg Larsson. Although Larsson professed himself a feminist, I can’t bring myself to believe him. It feels wrong to claim that a man who can abuse his characters in such a way is actually a feminist. I sometimes sense that he enjoys writing about the gross mistreatment of his female characters. Feminist or not, Larsson was certainly playing with fire—his own and Sweden’s in this book. (560)