The magistrate learns that being the only person to oppose something isn’t enough to incite real change. Without a large enough support group, one man’s opposition simply will not get you anywhere, except frustrated and miserable. The psychological burden of actively acknowledging and feeling cruelty is too much for one person to handle on their own. The magistrate learns on several occasions that his lone protest gets him nowhere, except humiliated and thrown in jail. Instead of winning glory he loses his dignity and torments himself psychologically with his own thoughts. “For now what I hear when I loosen my tongue and let it sail free is the subtle whining of a beggar,” he notes (149 Ink Edition). He is more like a begging loser than a righteous leader. The novel’s last sentence leaves the reader with the sense that the magistrate’s whole journey was perhaps pointless—for all the trouble he went through, nothing has come of it. He ponders, “Like much else nowadays I leave it feeling stupid, like a man who lost his way long ago but presses on along a road that may lead nowhere” (180).
The magistrate’s captivation with the barbarian girl teaches him that people can lose their humanity, but that it is futile to spend time and thought insisting on its existence in such people. In taking the beaten barbarian girl in, the magistrate felt a sort of duty to find and restore her emotions, her character, and her humanity. But he soon learned that she was in some sort of a frozen state—nothing seemed to move, please, or hurt her. She “believ[ed] in nothing” (94). Only after he returns her to her people does the magistrate understand that after her torture, “she was no longer fully human, sister to all of us. Certain sympathies died, certain movements of the heart became no longer possible to her” (94). His “guardianship” of her was an attempt to restore her to something that was no longer possible. After some experiences, a sense of humanity and purpose simply cannot be recovered. (337)