Tuesday, October 19, 2010

The Ellesmere Chaucer (Blog #6)


            Among the first manuscripts of The Canterbury Tales, the Ellesmere manuscript, also known as the Ellesmere Chaucer, holds an important place in literary and art history. The work is remembered today for both its textual and visual authority: it remains one of the best orderings of the tales and an epitome of medieval illuminated manuscripts.
            The significance of the Ellesmere Chaucer might best be understood with a description of how the Canterbury Tales have come down to us nearly six centuries later. The tales were always a work in progress for Chaucer. He wrote them in no particular order and left many unfinished. Moreover, unlike the unique Beowulf manuscript of which there is only one, over eighty different manuscripts, including fragments, have been identified. The problem deepens as none of these can be certainly dated in Chaucer's own lifetime, nor traced to a scribe directly employed or supervised by him. This means that nearly all the surviving manuscripts were written between 1400 and the time of Caxton's printing press less than a century later at which point the expense and tedium of hand-copying no longer seemed worthwhile. The Ellesmere manuscript is thought to have been written shortly following Chaucer’s death and possibly by the scribe Adam Pinkhurst, a man employed by Chaucer himself. The manuscript is therefore noted as a critical source for efforts to reconstruct Chaucer's original text and intentions. As Pinkhurst was acquainted with Chaucer, he might have had a better insight into Chaucer’s intentions for the Tales. Other arrangements of the stories have been tried, but the “Ellesmere order” (with a couple of changes) still serves to this day as the basic arrangement.
            The book itself remains of great worth not only for its textual contribution but also for its outstanding workmanship. Fortunately, the original Ellesmere manuscript survives to this day largely undamaged, due to the fact that it has rested in libraries since around 1600. The manuscript is beautifully bound and printed on 232 pages of the finest quality thin vellum, sound and flexible. The page dimensions are noteworthy, nearly 16 x 11 inches. However, the main glory of the manuscript is the lavish illumination and illustration, in which the Ellesmere is easily unrivaled. On no less than seventy-one pages large foliated initials are joined to "demi-vinet" borders (conventionalized vines), in gold and other colors, framing the text on three sides. Opposite the first line of each tale is the figure of that tale’s narrator. There are twenty-three highly individualized portraits, including a very famous one of Chaucer himself. The miniatures are of great charm and interest and all show a perfect understanding of the text they are intended to illustrate, unusual for medieval illustrations. Studies of illumination indicate that the manuscript was probably the work of three to four craftsmen and, interestingly, not of monks. The evidence suggests that the text, border, and figures were all done at the same time, also unusual for medieval manuscripts.  

The first page of the knight's tale. The demi-vinet and the knight's miniature are both visible.
            Thus the significance of the Ellesmere Chaucer is impressive: it is one of the two or three earliest manuscripts, one of the best authorities for the order of the tales, and one of the most splendid examples of medieval bookmaking. The Ellesmere Chaucer is easily the finest manuscript of The Canterbury Tales and is in every respect worthy of Chaucer himself.
A portrait of Chaucer.

Sunday, October 17, 2010

The Man of Law


          Chaucer presents the “Sergeant of the Lawe” exactly as a man of law: he strictly follows regulations and does nothing against the law. He owns his land without legal impediments and assures that all his purchasing “might not been infect” (322). Apparently, “every statut coude he plein by rote” (329) or, in other words, he could recite every statue by heart. He had memorized all of the laws, court cases, and decisions in England over the last 300 years and could therefore, Chaucer contends, write the most perfect legal document. Chaucer here is poking fun at the notion that memorization is akin to knowledge. The judge is wise and great, not because he is a great thinker or moralist, but because he can recite a law on demand.
            Despite his legal fastidiousness, the lawyer also has a bit of a more indulgent streak in him. He has grown rich lately, buying many nice robes and pursuing the path of a wealthy and powerful landowner.  He seems to enjoy this newfound reputation, meeting often in the prestigious porch of St. Paul’s Cathedral with his clients. He obviously takes pleasure in creating a persona about him to maintain his stature. As Chaucer writes: “Nowher so bisy a man as he her nas; / And yit he seemed bisier than he was” (324-5). The lawyer plainly likes to give off the impression of being wanted and valued by others for his work, however false this reputation may be. 
            Although it’s hard to tell, Chaucer was probably satirizing both the judicial system and the justice in this short snapshot. Chaucer mocks the so-called wisdom of the judge who really only memorizes court cases and decisions rather than thinking for himself. Perhaps Chaucer also hoped to express some appreciation for the emerging middle class. Most likely between the aristocratic and the middle class, the lawyer was a character who could travel across boundaries and expeirience the glamour of the wealthy and the streets of London. The lawyer does not fit into the traditional three estates and must therefore secure his high-ranking status through hard work, bragging, and in general being a bit of a poser. (361)