Sunday, March 13, 2011

Waiting for Enlightenment?


            The magistrate learns that being the only person to oppose something isn’t enough to incite real change. Without a large enough support group, one man’s opposition simply will not get you anywhere, except frustrated and miserable. The psychological  burden of actively acknowledging and feeling cruelty is too much for one person to handle on their own. The magistrate learns on several occasions that his lone protest gets him nowhere, except humiliated and thrown in jail.  Instead of winning glory he loses his dignity and torments himself psychologically with his own thoughts. “For now what I hear when I loosen my tongue and let it sail free is the subtle whining of a beggar,” he notes (149 Ink Edition). He is more like a begging loser than a righteous leader. The novel’s last sentence leaves the reader with the sense that the magistrate’s whole journey was perhaps pointless—for all the trouble he went through, nothing has come of it. He ponders, “Like much else nowadays I leave it feeling stupid, like a man who lost his way long ago but presses on along a road that may lead nowhere” (180).
            The magistrate’s captivation with the barbarian girl teaches him that people can lose their humanity, but that it is futile to spend time and thought insisting on its existence in such people. In taking the beaten barbarian girl in, the magistrate felt a sort of duty to find and restore her emotions, her character, and her humanity. But he soon learned that she was in some sort of a frozen state—nothing seemed to move, please, or hurt her. She “believ[ed] in nothing” (94). Only after he returns her to her people does the magistrate understand that after her torture, “she was no longer fully human, sister to all of us. Certain sympathies died, certain movements of the heart became no longer possible to her” (94). His “guardianship” of her was an attempt to restore her to something that was no longer possible. After some experiences, a sense of humanity and purpose simply cannot be recovered. (337)

Monday, March 7, 2011

Zealotry in Zimbabwe

Zimbabwe has long been known for its violent past and present. Under current president Robert Mugabe (who has been ruling for over three decades), vicious land redistribution has forced people off their property, sky-high inflation destroyed the economy, and rigged elections keep people in a state of fear and ensure Mugabe's power over a powerless population. During "elections" in 2008, the secret police or Joint Operations Command (JOC) orchestrated political violence that rocked the country, with hundreds killed  and thousands more beaten, tortured, wrongfully arrested and forced from their homes. "This country is now effectively run by a military junta," opposition leader Tsvangirai told reporters in Harare.

The opposition said its supporters were being systematically targeted





Sunday, February 13, 2011

Mr. Darcy Regrets: commentaries on the BBC film


  • The two texts take a better look into Darcy’s character, evaluating his feelings and how to translate them on screen. There isn’t really a thesis, except for maybe that despite his lack of emotion to the outside world, Darcy is really undergoing an emotional hurricane inside and that it takes all of his awkward behavior just to restrain himself.
  • Colin Firth talks about his search to discover Darcy’s inner state of mind in order to understand how to act like Darcy would have. He commented that he actually ended up emotionally defending him in several situations. For example, he says that when approaching the proposal scene, he had to get completely in Darcy’s head. He knew that he couldn’t play it as if he knew he were being shocking and arrogant, but instead make his condescending speech the most reasonable thing to say. Colin Firth says he imagined Darcy to be saying that, despite all the family rage their engagement would cause, the judgments he would receive, his love for Elizabeth is so overwhelming that these objections are rendered insignificant.  And from this point of view, it’s terribly romantic. Colin says, “I was a bit hurt when we filmed it, and everybody thought I was saying something terrible: I had got myself so far into the notion that he had come in with a really charming thing to say.”
  • I also really like Colin’s analysis of how and why Darcy fell in love with Elizabeth. Colin explains that Darcy is very bored, citing a quote that helped him understand his character’s behavior a lot—“A man who is eligible needs to entertain no one.” He never needs to respond or put himself forward. So Elizabeth’s attraction is that she gives him a chance to respond. As Colin says, she’s “probably the first opportunity he’s ever had in his life to be the pursuer rather than the pursued: it’s irresistible.” And that’s why Elizabeth’s eyes become so marking a physical feature. I think that Colin sums up Darcy’s lasting fascination with her from a man’s perspective when he says, “What starts off as intriguing becomes profoundly erotic for him.”
  • I completely agree with everything Colin says in this interview about Darcy’s character. To me, his behavior makes perfect sense and is actually quite endearing.
  • The second article also examines Darcy’s inner turmoil, but takes a different angle by examining the emphasis the film places on his physical expressions. In the film Darcy is seen swimming, riding, playing billiards, bathing, fencing, and giving doting stares. This physical activity is a way to show the depth of Darcy’s bodily struggle with his emotions. When engaging in physical activity, Darcy can be himself, but in society he can’t express himself to the same degree. The longing stares Colin gives are a representation of his struggle to express his desires.
  • Cheryl Nixon examines this theory in an analysis of the proposal scene. She says, “In the film adaptation, Elizabeth’s rejection…can be read as a rejection due to his inability to voice his full emotions. Compared with his doting stares, billiard playing, bathing, fencing, and swimming, Darcy’s proposal seems restrained; although he expresses his love, his is unable to put his hidden emotions into a verbal vocabulary that matches the intensity of his physical vocabulary.”
  • I wholly agree with Nixon’s perspective on the depth of Darcy’s physical expression of his emotions. Thinking about it more, I realized that those scenes where Darcy engages in physical activity actually do add to the sexual tension the book lacked. While the film’s depiction is a more modern take on his behavior, I can still imagine Darcy acting exactly so. It just aligns so well with his awkward habit of pacing back and forth or just simply not talking to Elizabeth when walking alone with her or calling upon her. He has to release his emotional tension somehow.
  • I also had never thought of their relationship as being erotic, certainly Jane Austen would not say so, but the underlying tension and flirtation does actually create that effect. With Colin’s description of Darcy’s erotic perusal paired with his physical portrayal of Darcy, Pride and Prejudice suddenly seems a lot more sexy.  

Monday, December 6, 2010

If Theater Be the Food of Life, Play On!


            As a theater buff, I can safely say that the Southwest Shakespeare Company’s production of Twelfth Night was really quite good and definitely the most enjoyable Shakespeare I’ve seen. I was surprised by the intimacy of the setting. The other Shakepseare performances I’ve attended were staged in large theaters, so I really liked the small theater-in-the-round in Mesa. It was great to be so close to the actors and see their expressions so clearly. I also enjoyed being on such familiar terms with the text. I knew what jokes were coming and had a fun time comparing and contrasting the performance to what I had always imagined took place. Besides the reality that Alex Kost is actually Viola dressed as Cesario (the similarity is creepy!) , I picked up on some notable differences and interpretations of the text.
            First of all, I would like to say that I think the actor who played Sir Toby did a fabulous job. He really added a whole new dimension of comedy to the play. In my head I had never imagined him to be so boisterous and enthusiastic but instead rather annoying and conniving. This Toby was both rambunctious and mischievous, always pushing the limits of decency with his drunken walk, song, and dance and loud voice. I also noticed that the director did a good job of developing the romance between Sir Toby and Maria. There were moments while reading the play that I thought the two would make a good couple, but their marriage still came as a bit of a shock to me. However, in this production the body language—they kissed once and hugged several times—between the couple made a lot of sense to me. I had wondered where exactly Toby was getting his ideas that Maria “adored him” when all they appeared to be doing was collaborating.
            Second, for me the live drama added more comedy to Orsino’s character, whose over-the-top manner made me laugh out loud on several occasions. The actor did a wonderful job playing up Orsino’s some might say “drama queen” personality, placing extra emphasis on his tone of voice and confident body language. I loved how he was always being rolled in and out on a chaise longue or bathtub. It really added to the dramatic effect of his character. As with Sir Toby and Maria, Orsino and Viola had a lot more on-stage chemistry than I had personally envisioned. I especially liked the scene when the two were playing cards and viola insists that women love as much or more than men. While reading the scene, I did not picture the aura between the two to be so flirtatious and full of subtlety. The stage directing was brilliant. There was so much tension in the scene, particularly when Orsino and Viola were so close they could almost kiss each other.
            Finally, the most obvious difference—the actual setting of the play—I was not so fond of. The fact that no mention was made of Russia and the costumes and music were only partly Russian in influence, although the setting was supposed to be Siberia, made me a bit confused. In general, I have to say that I am not a huge fan of re-setting Shakespeare in different time periods and locations. I understand the logic behind it—that Shakespeare is timeless and is rather a commentary on human nature and relations than on historical events or time periods—but I feel that it is unnecessary and can detract from the charm. Call me a traditionalist, but I like the Shakespearian garb and renaissance sets! Maybe, it’s just that I have yet to see a re-setting done well. Nonetheless, in all I had a wonderful time and thoroughly enjoyed spending my Sunday afternoon watching Twelfth Night. (630)

Monday, November 15, 2010

Is it All an Illusion?


            Illusion, the very word seems to be alluding its own meaning. In my initial research, I’ve come to find that the word is an illusion itself, meaning more than I thought it originally did. It may seem odd, but I like the sly personality of the word. An illusion can be anything we want it to be, so long as it deceives the eye or mind in some way. Everything and anything can be an illusion—are humans illusions of themselves? Is life an illusion? Or perhaps it might be better to ask: what isn’t an illusion? While pondering these deep questions, I’ve had some time to do a bit of research on the etymology, definitions, and use of the word illusion.
            The word in its present form is old French from the mid fourteenth century, but its roots (as those of most French words) are Latin. The Latin definition is a mocking, jesting, or irony and the Latin verb illudere translates as to mock. Thus, the original old French meaning was a mocking or act of deception. This correlates with the first definition listed in the Oxford English Dictionary (OED), the action of deriding or mocking. Furthermore, the word has always held the connotation of deception and trickery. One of the word’s first uses is in Richard Rolle of Hampole’s prose, where “illusyone of de enemy” is mentioned. Interestingly, illusions often seem to be associated with the devil. In Shakespeare’s Henry VIII the surveyor speaks of the “devil’s illusions”. This relationship with the devil connects illusion with magic. Illusion developed to mean an apparition or ghost and is often mentioned in the context of magic. In Hamlet Horatio cries, “Stay illusion!” to the ghost of the late king of Denmark. However it seems that illusion did not develop one of its more modern meaning of an “apparent perception of an external object when no such object is present” until the 1770s (OED). There appears to have been a kind of resurgence in the popularity of illusions. Houdini, the great illusionist, captured the world with his unworldly magic acts while Freud and other psychoanalysis emphasized the illusion of the subconscious. All of a sudden illusion became pop culture, further evident in the trendy Op Art of the 50s and 60s. I’d like to investigate how “the art of illusion” had its own renaissance in the fields of psychoanalysis, art, and magic in the 1900s.
            So far its been interesting to note where the word illusion has not come up. There is no trace of the word in the bible, as it is too young for such an old text. It does not once come up in Any of Lewis Carroll’s works, which was quite surprising to me considering the hallucinogenic descriptions of Wonderland. There isn’t a trace of it in Jane Austen’s writing or several other Victorian authors. It seems odd to me that illusion was such a rarely used word. I believe that its use must have greatly increased thanks to its famous proponents from a variety of spheres in the twentieth century. (513)

Tuesday, October 19, 2010

The Ellesmere Chaucer (Blog #6)


            Among the first manuscripts of The Canterbury Tales, the Ellesmere manuscript, also known as the Ellesmere Chaucer, holds an important place in literary and art history. The work is remembered today for both its textual and visual authority: it remains one of the best orderings of the tales and an epitome of medieval illuminated manuscripts.
            The significance of the Ellesmere Chaucer might best be understood with a description of how the Canterbury Tales have come down to us nearly six centuries later. The tales were always a work in progress for Chaucer. He wrote them in no particular order and left many unfinished. Moreover, unlike the unique Beowulf manuscript of which there is only one, over eighty different manuscripts, including fragments, have been identified. The problem deepens as none of these can be certainly dated in Chaucer's own lifetime, nor traced to a scribe directly employed or supervised by him. This means that nearly all the surviving manuscripts were written between 1400 and the time of Caxton's printing press less than a century later at which point the expense and tedium of hand-copying no longer seemed worthwhile. The Ellesmere manuscript is thought to have been written shortly following Chaucer’s death and possibly by the scribe Adam Pinkhurst, a man employed by Chaucer himself. The manuscript is therefore noted as a critical source for efforts to reconstruct Chaucer's original text and intentions. As Pinkhurst was acquainted with Chaucer, he might have had a better insight into Chaucer’s intentions for the Tales. Other arrangements of the stories have been tried, but the “Ellesmere order” (with a couple of changes) still serves to this day as the basic arrangement.
            The book itself remains of great worth not only for its textual contribution but also for its outstanding workmanship. Fortunately, the original Ellesmere manuscript survives to this day largely undamaged, due to the fact that it has rested in libraries since around 1600. The manuscript is beautifully bound and printed on 232 pages of the finest quality thin vellum, sound and flexible. The page dimensions are noteworthy, nearly 16 x 11 inches. However, the main glory of the manuscript is the lavish illumination and illustration, in which the Ellesmere is easily unrivaled. On no less than seventy-one pages large foliated initials are joined to "demi-vinet" borders (conventionalized vines), in gold and other colors, framing the text on three sides. Opposite the first line of each tale is the figure of that tale’s narrator. There are twenty-three highly individualized portraits, including a very famous one of Chaucer himself. The miniatures are of great charm and interest and all show a perfect understanding of the text they are intended to illustrate, unusual for medieval illustrations. Studies of illumination indicate that the manuscript was probably the work of three to four craftsmen and, interestingly, not of monks. The evidence suggests that the text, border, and figures were all done at the same time, also unusual for medieval manuscripts.  

The first page of the knight's tale. The demi-vinet and the knight's miniature are both visible.
            Thus the significance of the Ellesmere Chaucer is impressive: it is one of the two or three earliest manuscripts, one of the best authorities for the order of the tales, and one of the most splendid examples of medieval bookmaking. The Ellesmere Chaucer is easily the finest manuscript of The Canterbury Tales and is in every respect worthy of Chaucer himself.
A portrait of Chaucer.

Sunday, October 17, 2010

The Man of Law


          Chaucer presents the “Sergeant of the Lawe” exactly as a man of law: he strictly follows regulations and does nothing against the law. He owns his land without legal impediments and assures that all his purchasing “might not been infect” (322). Apparently, “every statut coude he plein by rote” (329) or, in other words, he could recite every statue by heart. He had memorized all of the laws, court cases, and decisions in England over the last 300 years and could therefore, Chaucer contends, write the most perfect legal document. Chaucer here is poking fun at the notion that memorization is akin to knowledge. The judge is wise and great, not because he is a great thinker or moralist, but because he can recite a law on demand.
            Despite his legal fastidiousness, the lawyer also has a bit of a more indulgent streak in him. He has grown rich lately, buying many nice robes and pursuing the path of a wealthy and powerful landowner.  He seems to enjoy this newfound reputation, meeting often in the prestigious porch of St. Paul’s Cathedral with his clients. He obviously takes pleasure in creating a persona about him to maintain his stature. As Chaucer writes: “Nowher so bisy a man as he her nas; / And yit he seemed bisier than he was” (324-5). The lawyer plainly likes to give off the impression of being wanted and valued by others for his work, however false this reputation may be. 
            Although it’s hard to tell, Chaucer was probably satirizing both the judicial system and the justice in this short snapshot. Chaucer mocks the so-called wisdom of the judge who really only memorizes court cases and decisions rather than thinking for himself. Perhaps Chaucer also hoped to express some appreciation for the emerging middle class. Most likely between the aristocratic and the middle class, the lawyer was a character who could travel across boundaries and expeirience the glamour of the wealthy and the streets of London. The lawyer does not fit into the traditional three estates and must therefore secure his high-ranking status through hard work, bragging, and in general being a bit of a poser. (361)